Fixation of Scaphoid Fracture

Definition

Treatment depends on where the break is, whether the pieces have moved, and how well you can manage in a cast. Metal screws or wires are used to hold the bone in place until it heals.

The size and place of the cut depend on which part of the scaphoid is broken. Sometimes the screws and wires can be put in through a tiny cut (1 to 2 mm).

In other cases, a larger incision is needed to line up the fragments of the scaphoid properly. A bone graft is sometimes needed, mostly when the bone has not healed (non-union). This graft can be taken from the forearm bone of the same arm, or hip.

Who is this operation for? 

Indications for surgery:

  • Unstable scaphoid seen on X-ray or CT scan. This will impact the potential for healing with non-operative treatment.
  • Displacement between 2 fractured bones >1 mm.
  • Angle between the wrist bone and lunate bone (radiolunate) is >15 degrees.
  • Angle between the scaphoid and lunate bone (scapholunate) is >60 degrees.

What are the benefits of the operation?

Fixing the bone through a small cut does less damage to the tissue and blood supply around the scaphoid than a larger open cut.

Risks of not having the surgery

If an unstable break is treated in a cast, it is more likely to heal slowly, heal out of place or not heal at all. The joint can also get stiff, and you may need more time off work.

Complications

The risks and complications of a Fixation of Scaphoid Fractures:

General complications:

  • Bleeding
  • Infection
  • Pain

Specific complications:

  • Non-union
  • Mal-union
  • Scaphoid shortening or subsidence due to secondary screw penetration
  • Neurovascular injury (cutaneous nerve, radial artery)
  • Incorrect placement of fixation screw
  • Failure to recognise concomitant injuries

Before the operation

Preadmission Clinic | Preparing for Surgery

Before your operation, you will go to the pre-admission clinic. This checks you are fit for surgery and does any tests you need.

During the visit, you will be seen by a

  • Doctor
  • Nurse
  • Anaesthetist (if necessary)

Tests

Tests that may be ordered for you include:

  • blood tests
  • X-ray wrist
  • Urine Test
  • ECG

Preparing Your Skin

Your skin should be free of sores, rashes and infections before surgery. If you have any, ask your surgeon how to get your skin healthy first.

Medications

Your team will tell you which medicines to stop or keep taking before surgery.

Tip

Carry a list of your medicines, with the name, dose and how often you take each one.

About the Operation

Incision and exposure: A cut is made over the bump at the base of the thumb. The scaphoid is then approached through a few longitudinal incisions on the wrist. 

Debridement: Your doctor cleans out scar tissue from the part of the bone that has not healed. 

Reduction: Dental picks or K-wires are then inserted to align the fragmented bones into reduction. Double-checking guidewire position is done with multiple radiographic views. 

Fixation: The K-wires serve as a guide for the screws (cannulated screw or Herbert screw). 

Wound closure: The surgical incisions are closed with stitches.

After the Operation

After the surgery, the incisions are closed with stitches and a dressing is applied. You are required to wear a cast or splint while the fracture heals. 

How long you wear a cast or splint depends on the type of problem. 

Keep the wrist raised to limit pain and swelling.

Recovery and Rehabilitation 

Every scaphoid fracture is different. If a stable break in the middle of the bone was fixed early (within 4 weeks), you will usually only need a few days in a dressing, then a removable splint. 

Breaks near the top of the bone are less stable and often need a cast for 6 weeks or more. Your doctor may refer you for a physiotherapy course if necessary. 

Here are a few steps to help you care for your wrist after surgery:

  • Wear your bandage or splint as directed by your doctor. Keep the dressing clean and dry.
  • Shower as necessary. Cover your wrist with plastic to keep the dressing dry.
  • Keep your hand raised above the level of your heart for the first 2–3 days after surgery. This reduces swelling. 
  • Avoid gripping objects tightly or lifting with your affected arm
  • Do the exercises taught to you in hospital
  • If your job requires heavy lifting, you may not be able to return for several weeks
  • Do not participate in contact sports, climb ladders or trees
  • Take pain medication as required

F.A.Q.s | Frequently Asked Questions

What are the alternative treatments to having a Fixation of Scaphoid Fractures?

Short arm thumb spica cast / long arm thumb spica cast (closed treatment)

Are there important things I need to tell my doctors?

  • Fever and chills
  • Fingers that are pale and blue
  • Increased tenderness, swelling and redness of the incision
  • Inability to move fingers or hands
  • Any drainage from the incision
  • Severe pain with or without activity